The Baptist Times

mailbox-smallMailbox - See what others are thinking or have your say in the online letters' page.

Arts, Culture and Sports - Books Book review: There Are No Strong People By Jeff Lucas
Book review: There Are No Strong People By Jeff Lucas Print
Thursday, 10 May 2012 15:40

"If you are a little squeamish, skip the next few paragraphs" - so writes Jeff Lucas towards the end of his latest book about Samson. Some might suggest he place this "health warning" at the beginning of the book - "If you are a bit squeamish, skip the book!"

lucasThere Are No Strong People By Jeff Lucas CWR: £9.99 ISBN: 9781853456244 Reviewer: Martin Poole

Undoubtedly Jeff's treatment of Samson is controversial as he seeks to dump all of today's sex obsessed culture on to this Old Testament figure. He repeatedly locates sexual innuendos which have probably bypassed most students of scripture, including this reviewer, in the past - the reader must decide on the accuracy.

There is much of worth to think through as Jeff uses Samson to shine a light on some of the strong treacherous currents that swirl around the individual Christian and church communities today e.g. How to be distinctive and not merge with culture; the issue of internet pornography; the danger of "success" in Christian leadership, the Christian leader who falls etc.

The most powerful chapter for me was "Jesus works at the rubbish dump" where Jeff looks at Samson being "led by his eyes and his loins" and observes how God is able to transform the scraps and junk of our foolishness into treasure.

However there is also an inherent danger that some will retune the message from Jeff's explicit and often speculative commentary that if it's OK for God's chosen judge to act at times as a Philistine sex tourist, it validates any sexual activity. Jeff would argue that his unexpurgated treatment of the Samson narrative simply supports his basic contention that the are no strong people but rather people with different strengths.

On balance strong stuff, written with humour, but needing to be read with care.

 

The Revd Martin Poole is a retired Baptist minister (Penarth, Godalming, Eastleigh) and is currently Lymington Centre Manager for Christians Against Poverty


Last Updated on Tuesday, 22 May 2012 15:00
 

Comments  

 
+1 #1 Jeff Lucas 2012-05-22 07:01
Greetings Martin

I don't normally respond to reviews, but feel the need to comment on yours, because it contains what I feel is a very serious charge - namely, and I quote, 'there is also an inherent danger that some will retune the message from Jeff's explicit and often speculative commentary that if its OK for God's chosen judge to act at times as a Philistine sex tourist, it validates any sexual activity'. I am quite staggered by this comment, and have to wonder if you have read the whole book, which repeatedly affirms that our actions have terrible consequences, that we should be especially diligent in church contexts, that the things we play with will end up making a plaything of us, and that Samson came to a terrible end - a blinded captive - because of his profligate lifestyle. For any reader to think that this allows for a lifestyle of license would mean that they are not retuning the message, but trashing the instrument and playing their own tune.

Also, you mentioned that I bought out various hidden sexual innuendos that are in the story, and seem to suggest that because you were previously unaware of them, therefore they must be suspect. I protest: the book is thoroughly footnoted, and where I have mentioned the various 'riddles' that are contained in the text, I do so with full references to the Talmudic sources that give rise, not to speculations, but to insight into Hebrew literary style.

I hope this clarifies and helps you in your concerns.

Warmest regards

Jeff
Quote
 

By A Web Design

Quick Links

News

Contact Us

Advertise

About Us Local Email: editor@baptisttimes.co.uk For all advertising queries contact
Jobs National Telephone: 01235 517677         Hinton Media Services Ltd:
Baptist Voice
International Find us on Facebook facebook Telephone: 01932 888417/07724 721747
Privacy policy   Follow us on Twitter twitter Email: fiona@hintonmediaservices.com
Site Map